The Starling Model
Evaluation, Impact and Implementation
An integrated analytical report combining research evidence, sector insights and practical application to strengthen foster carer support, retention and recruitment.
Contents
Section 1: Evaluation, Impact and Research
Foreword and Introduction
- 1. Key Messages from the Evidence and Research Base
- 2. Literature Review
- 3. Comparative Analysis of Present Service Models
Section 2: The Model
- 1. Behind the name
- 2. Building on established practice
- 3. Strengthening System Capacity and Sufficiency
- 4. The Model
- 5.Operational Rollout – Scaling Across England
Foreword by Co-Founder Sarah Anderson
We are facing a crisis: the system is some 6,000–8,000 foster carers short, recruitment has stalled, and too many children are placed in residential homes when family-based fostering would better meet their needs.
Every unnecessary move compounds the trauma these children carry, as carers struggle without the support, education, and skills necessary to stabilise, nurture, and heal them.
Children grow into young people and eventually leave care, and society has a duty to ensure they do not leave homeless, unemployed, or caught in cycles of prison, homelessness, or mental ill-health, areas where care leavers remain disproportionately represented, sometimes as high as 35%.
Their journeys often strip away critical attachments and relationships, and only 7% achieve GCSEs, fewer progress to further education, and far too many leave care dependent on benefits or NEET.
Foster care can only succeed when its foundations are strong. The scaffolding under those who provide care, the training, the support, the guidance, must be robust, so that children experience stability, healing, and the outcomes they deserve.
One of the system’s largest gaps lies in supporting foster carers, retaining those who are already providing care, and recruiting those who could.
The government has invested millions into foster carer retention in the past few years and currently, yet the bulk of this funding has been channelled into a single model that currently reaches only 4% of foster carers. While additional investment is earmarked, this heavily promoted approach is resource-intensive, difficult to scale, and complex to implement.
We are not critical of the model itself; it works well for some carers. But we are deeply concerned that the remaining 96% of foster carers, those who do not engage with it, who do not wish to, or who already operate effective, holistic approaches, have been largely overlooked. The limitations and challenges of this model have been closely guarded, and its drawbacks have rarely been acknowledged in broader discussions.
It is time to bring balance to the conversation. Every foster carer deserves support that is practical, inclusive, and adaptable, not a one-size-fits-all solution. Our focus must be on empowering the entire foster workforce, amplifying existing good practice, and ensuring investment reaches those who need it most.
It has also been evident through our engagement at the government level that, until now, there has been little else to invest in. In response, we have developed Starling, designed to complement existing provision, provide scalable, independent support, and ensure that every foster carer, and therefore every child in care, has the foundations to thrive.
The Starling Model is designed to complement, not compete with, existing frameworks, strengthening what already works while addressing the gaps that remain. It provides a resource-efficient, scalable solution that can be implemented rapidly, meeting both the immediate pressures of retention and the longer-term need for sustainable stability in the workforce.
We have set out to create an equal and inclusive approach, informed by the realities of the role in a way that other models cannot replicate, ensuring carers can access trusted spaces that are free from perceived hierarchies or conflicts of interest, while still working in constructive partnership with agencies and local authorities.
Children and young people deserve us to get this right; they should be at the centre of all we do and have the right to a stable, loving home where they feel they are loved and belong.
Sarah Anderson | Co-Founder
Introduction
This paper sets out the evidentiary case for The Starling Model of independent peer support and education. This not-for-profit model addresses a critical gap in the current fostering system by providing foster carers with a safe and trusted space to connect, share experiences, and access both emotional and practical support.
Importantly, the model is designed to operate in alignment with agency and local authority services, ensuring complementarity rather than duplication.
By embedding an independent but collaborative layer of support, it strengthens the overall ecosystem of provision, enhances carer resilience, and directly contributes to improved stability and outcomes for children in care.
The Starling Model, therefore, represents a unique opportunity for providers and local authorities to extend their support offer, demonstrate innovation in line with national priorities, and achieve measurable impact on recruitment, retention, and quality of care. It offers value for money through the prevention of placement breakdowns, reduced turnover, and improved long-term outcomes for children.
Drawing on research, reports, surveys, and academic literature, both contemporary and spanning several decades, it demonstrates the strategic and practical rationale for implementing an independent, scalable peer support community framework.
1. Key Messages from the Evidence and Research Base
Fostering is a uniquely demanding and complex role. Carers routinely support children who have experienced trauma, neglect, or disrupted attachments while navigating the expectations of local authorities, social workers, and legal frameworks. The intensity of the role can lead to social isolation, stress, and burnout, despite statutory and agency-based support (Nutt, 2006; Blythe et al., 2011; Rees Centre, 2019).
Evidence consistently identifies gaps in the availability, accessibility, and effectiveness of conventional support mechanisms. Peer support has emerged as a critical response, offering carers opportunities for shared learning, emotional validation, and practical guidance (Rees Centre, 2019; Newstone, 2008). Peer interactions take many forms, including structured group meetings, mentoring schemes, informal social events, helplines, and online forums. These interactions provide a combination of learning, empathy, and reassurance that is difficult to replicate through traditional statutory channels.
However, not all peer support is equally effective. Agency-led or in-house initiatives may be constrained by organisational priorities, inconsistent facilitation, or limited independence, potentially reducing their impact.”(Murray, 2007; Heath & Newstone, 2010).
Independent peer support, by contrast, that operates outside agency hierarchies, allows for objectivity, confidentiality, and trust. This independence ensures carers receive credible, practice-grounded advice and emotional support, free from internal organisational dynamics that could compromise openness. (Murray, 2007; Heath & Newstone, 2010).
The wider fostering context reinforces the need for effective peer support. High turnover and recruitment challenges continue to threaten placement stability, while carers’ wellbeing directly influences the quality of care and outcomes for children.
Evidence indicates that peer support can enhance carer retention, improve mental health, and contribute to placement stability, and peer-led recruitment, representing a cost-effective mechanism for strengthening the fostering system (Sinclair et al., Rhodes et al, Northwest Institute for Children and Families).
Research also highlights the psychosocial benefits of peer support. Carers gain confidence, normalise challenges, and reduce feelings of isolation when engaging in safe, non-judgmental, and carer-led networks (Allen & Vostanis, 2005; Golding & Picken, 2004; Warman et al., 2006).
Shared understanding and validation from peers provide emotional support that extends beyond practical guidance, creating informal mechanisms for offloading stress, discussing frustrations, and accessing practical help such as respite care. These factors contribute directly to placement stability and carers’ sustained engagement (The Fostering Network, 2009; Blythe et al., 2011; Northwest Institute for Children and Families, 2007).
While robust quantitative evidence linking peer support to measurable outcomes for children or carers remains limited, qualitative research consistently demonstrates its value. Independent, facilitated peer networks play a crucial role in sustaining carers’ effectiveness, resilience, and professional experience, complementing statutory and agency support structures (Rees Centre, 2019; Cole & Eamon, 2007).
Findings from the Independent Foster Carer’s Survey, 2024
The Independent Foster Carer’s Survey, capturing the perspectives of 2,500 carers and 14,500 written responses, exposes systemic pressures and gaps in support that directly undermine both child well-being and foster carer retention.
These findings highlight the urgent need for a model like Starling, which prioritises stability, education, and holistic attention to both the child’s and the household’s needs.
Carers are too often left to source their own support, with 45% reporting they have had to do so, while supervision is inconsistent: 63% have had multiple supervising social workers in the past two years, and 30% have not received the required six-weekly supervision.
Support structures are widely reported as inadequate: 77% of carers describe out-of-hours support as insufficient, and only 29% were given a choice in the support services they received.
Mental health pressures are significant, with 78% of carers reporting negative mental health impacts due to fostering. Alarmingly, 56% avoid seeking support for fear of professional repercussions.
The consequences for retention are stark: 75% of carers cite feeling undervalued as a reason for considering resignation, alongside 61% reporting burnout, 58% citing lack of support, and 56% highlighting the conduct of social workers.
The Starling Model is designed to close these gaps. By delivering consistent, accessible, and trauma-responsive support, it ensures carers feel valued, equipped, and able to maintain both their own well-being and that of the children in their care. Starling transforms systemic weaknesses into a framework that delivers stability, resilience, and sustainable care for all.
The Power of Peer Support: Why It Matters More Than Ever
Although foster carers receive statutory support through supervising social workers and agency programmes, research consistently highlights gaps in the availability, accessibility, and effectiveness of this support (Rees Centre, 2019).
Independent or externally moderated peer support is able to maintain objectivity, prioritise carers’ perspectives, and nurture an environment of genuine trust and shared understanding. This independence ensures that carers receive advice and emotional support that is both credible and grounded in real-world practice, free from internal organisational dynamics that can compromise openness.
The need for effective peer support is heightened by the wider challenges facing the fostering system. Whilst the number of fostering families remains insufficient, with high turnover and recruitment difficulties threatening placement stability for children in care. Evidence indicates that peer support can positively influence carer retention, mental health, and placement stability, providing a cost-effective mechanism to enhance outcomes for both carers and children (Sinclair et al., 2004; Rhodes et al., 2001; Northwest Institute for Children and Families, 2007).
A scalable, independent peer support model therefore addresses a critical strategic need: enhancing carer resilience, supporting social workers, and improving the experiences and outcomes of children in care.